Head to Head
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 12:10 | Paul Nicholson v Raymond van Barneveld | 5-2 |
Home History
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/07 10:00 | Andy Jenkins v Paul Nicholson | 5-4 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 15:20 | Paul Nicholson v David Evans | 2-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 14:00 | Paul Nicholson v Wessel Nijman | 3-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 12:10 | Paul Nicholson v Raymond van Barneveld | 5-2 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 10:00 | Mark Webster v Paul Nicholson | 4-5 |
| BDO World Championship 2019 | 2018/12/14 15:30 | Paul Nicholson v Kevin Burness | 0-3 |
| BDO World Championship 2019 | 2018/10/25 20:30 | Michael van Gerwen v Paul Nicholson | 6-2 |
| BDO World Championship 2019 | 2018/09/07 17:45 | Jeffrey de Graaf v Paul Nicholson | 6-5 |
Away History
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/07 10:45 | Raymond van Barneveld v Wessel Nijman | 2-5 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 14:30 | David Evans v Raymond van Barneveld | 5-3 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 13:35 | Mark Webster v Raymond van Barneveld | 5-4 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 12:10 | Paul Nicholson v Raymond van Barneveld | 5-2 |
| Icons of Darts Live League 2020 | 2020/04/06 10:40 | Raymond van Barneveld v Wessel Nijman | 1-5 |
| PDC World Championship 2020 | 2019/12/14 21:40 | Raymond van Barneveld v Darin Young | 1-3 |
| Players Championship Finals 2019 | 2019/11/24 13:45 | Raymond van Barneveld v Chris Dobey | 2-10 |
| Players Championship Finals 2019 | 2019/11/23 20:50 | Glen Durrant v Raymond van Barneveld | 3-10 |